Storybook in Navy vs Black on Black: Which Notebook Fits?
By Bullet Planners & Dot Grid Journals 160gsm pages | Paint Pens | Published: 2026-10-31
Category: Buying Guides
Compare the Storybook in Navy and Black on Black Wonderstruck notebooks on cover color, page style, size, and price to pick the right one for your journaling routine.
Quick answer
Choose the Storybook in Navy if you want a classic navy cover with gold detailing and the option to pick your page style and size. Choose the Black on Black Wonderstruck if you prefer a moody, textured black cover and want a ready-to-use B5 notebook with white pages.
Cover color sets the tone before you write a word
The Storybook in Navy uses deep blue vegan leather with ornate gold detailing, giving it a traditional, storybook feel that stands out on a desk. The Black on Black Wonderstruck takes the opposite approach: a charcoal buckram cover with an embossed celestial design that only reveals itself when light hits it. Neither is objectively better, but the navy reads as decorative and the black reads as understated. If you carry your notebook to meetings or classes, the black cover blends in more easily; if you want a journal that feels like an object worth displaying, the navy does that job.
Page style and size flexibility differ
The Storybook in Navy lets you choose both page style and size, so you can match the notebook to your preferred layout and carry format. The Black on Black Wonderstruck is listed as a B5 notebook with white pages, so the size and page color are fixed. That makes the Wonderstruck simpler to buy if B5 and white pages already match your routine, but less adaptable if you are still experimenting with layouts. The Storybook in Navy is the safer pick when you are unsure which page style you will use most.
Price and value trade-off
At catalog prices, the Storybook in Navy is USD 33.55 (compared with USD 55.00) and the Black on Black Wonderstruck is USD 29.11 (compared with USD 41.00). The Storybook costs more but gives you page style and size choices; the Wonderstruck costs less and keeps the decision simple. If budget is the deciding factor, the Wonderstruck is the lower-cost entry. If you want to configure the notebook to your exact preferences, the Storybook's higher price buys that flexibility.
Key trade-offs at a glance
- Cover color and finish: Navy vegan leather with gold detailing feels traditional and decorative; black buckram with embossed celestial design feels subtle and textured. Pick the finish that matches where you will use the notebook most.
- Page style and size options: Storybook in Navy offers selectable page style and size; Black on Black Wonderstruck is fixed as a B5 notebook with white pages. If you are still testing layouts, the Storybook's options reduce the risk of buying the wrong format.
- Price versus flexibility: Storybook in Navy is USD 33.55 (compare USD 55.00); Black on Black Wonderstruck is USD 29.11 (compare USD 41.00). The lower-priced Wonderstruck is the simpler buy; the Storybook's extra cost pays for configurability.
Product facts
- Storybook in Navy | Books: Vegan leather cover in navy with ornate gold detailing; available in multiple page styles and sizes. You can choose the page style and size that match your journaling habits instead of adapting to a fixed format.
Storybook in Navy | Books - B5: Black on Black Wonderstruck White Pages: B5 size with white pages and a black buckram cover featuring an embossed celestial design. The fixed B5 format and white pages suit writers who already know they prefer a larger page and a clean background.
B5: Black on Black Wonderstruck White Pages
Which notebook is right for you?
Best for
- Writers who want a classic navy cover with gold accents and the ability to choose page style and size
- Journalers who are still experimenting with layouts and want flexibility
Not for
- Buyers who want a ready-to-use B5 notebook with white pages and no configuration decisions
- Shoppers looking for the lowest-priced option between the two
